Get Appraisal

What to do with Inherited Coins: A Comprehensive Guide to Understanding and Valuing Your Numismatic Legacy

Have you recently inherited a great collection of coins from a loved one? Inherited coins can hold sentimental value, historical interest, and even financial worth. Inheriting a coin collection can be a bittersweet experience. On the one hand, you’ve received a potentially valuable legacy; on the other, you might feel overwhelmed by the responsibility of managing an unfamiliar collection. If you’re unsure what to do with your newfound treasure, this guide will help you understand your options and make informed decisions about what to do with old coins.

Understanding Your Coin Collection:- Most Common Inherited Coins

The first step in your numismatic journey is to gain a clear understanding of what you’ve inherited. Coin collections come in various forms, each with its own unique characteristics and potential value. Some collections might consist primarily of travel souvenirs or foreign coins brought back from overseas trips. These often hold more sentimental than monetary value, but can still be fascinating pieces of history.

Another common type of inherited collection includes Proof and Mint sets. These were particularly popular in the 1960s and 1970s when coin collecting saw a surge in popularity. While these sets are generally common, some can still hold significant value, especially if they’re older or contain rare minting errors.

You might also find yourself in possession of a collection of commonly circulated coins. These could include wheat pennies, Morgan silver dollars, or even more recent coins that were simply set aside over the years. While many of these might not be particularly valuable, there’s always the possibility of finding a rare date or mint mark that could be worth a substantial sum.

Lastly, you might be fortunate enough to inherit a serious collector’s assemblage. These collections often contain rare, high-grade coins that can be extremely valuable. If this is the case, it’s crucial to approach the valuation and potential sale with extra care and expertise.

Assessing the Value of Your Inherited Coins

Determining the value of your inherited coins can be a complex process, especially if you’re new to the world of numismatics. The value of a coin depends on various factors, including its rarity, condition, and historical significance.

One of the first things to consider is the coin’s metal content. Gold and silver coins, for instance, have an intrinsic value based on their precious metal content. However, the numismatic value of a coin can far exceed its metal value, particularly for rare or well-preserved specimens.

The condition of a coin is paramount in determining its value. Coins are graded on a scale from Poor (P-1) to Perfect Uncirculated (MS-70). Even small differences in condition can result in significant price variations. What might look like a pristine coin to an untrained eye could have subtle imperfections that impact its grade and, consequently, its value.

For an accurate assessment, it’s advisable to consult with a professional coin dealer or a reputable coin shop. 

The Crucial Role of Professional Coin Grading

For valuable coins, professional grading can significantly impact their worth and marketability. Professional grading services, such as NGC (Numismatic Guaranty Corporation) or PCGS (Professional Coin Grading Service), provide an objective assessment of a coin’s condition and authenticity.

The grading process involves a thorough examination of the coin by expert numismatists. They assess various aspects such as wear, luster, strike, and preservation. The coin is then assigned a numerical grade and encapsulated in a tamper-evident holder, which protects the coin and includes important information about its certification.

Professional grading offers several benefits. It provides an objective assessment of the coin’s condition, which can be crucial when it comes to selling. It also helps protect against counterfeits, which is particularly important for rare or valuable coins. Lastly, graded coins often have increased marketability, as buyers can be confident in the coin’s authenticity and condition.

At our coin shop in the Bay Area, we can help you determine which coins in your inherited collection might benefit from professional grading. We can also assist with the submission process, ensuring your valuable coins are handled with the utmost care.

To Keep or to Sell: Making the Right Decision

Once you have a clear understanding of your collection’s content and value, you’ll need to decide whether to keep or sell the coins. This decision can be influenced by various factors, including sentimental value, financial needs, and personal interest in numismatics.

If you decide to keep the collection, consider proper storage and insurance to protect your investment. Coins should be stored in appropriate holders in a cool, dry place to prevent damage. For valuable collections, a safety deposit box or home safe might be advisable.

If you choose to sell, there are several options available. Local coin shops, like Mountain View US and Foreign Coins, offer the advantage of face-to-face interactions and immediate payment. Online marketplaces can provide access to a wider audience but come with their own set of challenges, including shipping risks and potential fraud.

For rare or exceptionally valuable pieces, auction houses might be the best option. They can reach a global audience of serious collectors, potentially maximizing your return. However, this process can be lengthy and involves commissions.

Maximizing the Potential of Your Inherited Coins

When handling inherited coins, it’s important to be aware of some common pitfalls. Here are a few mistakes to avoid:

Cleaning Coins

It might seem tempting to clean tarnished or dirty coins to make them look more appealing, but this can drastically reduce their value. Cleaning can damage the coin’s surface, erasing important historical details and reducing its appeal to collectors. Coins are valued more when they retain their original condition, including natural patina or wear.

Making Hasty Decisions

The emotional impact of inheriting a coin collection can lead to impulsive decisions, such as rushing to sell the coins without understanding their true value. Take the time to research and explore your options. Consider factors like market demand, historical significance, and rarity. A well-informed decision can help you maximize the financial and historical value of your collection.

Trusting Non-Expert Appraisals

Friends or family members might offer to appraise your collection, but unless they are experienced numismatists, their evaluations may not be accurate. Non-expert appraisals can lead to undervaluing your coins, resulting in potential financial loss. Always seek professional appraisals from reputable coin dealers or appraisers who specialize in numismatics.


At Mountain View US and Foreign Coins, we understand the complexities of managing inherited coins. Our experienced team can guide you through these potential pitfalls, offering expert appraisals, valuation advice, and insights into market trends. We aim to help you make informed decisions about your inherited collection, preserving both its sentimental and financial value.

Inherited Coin Collection Taxes: Do I Need to Worry About Them?


When you inherit a coin collection, there are generally no immediate tax concerns. However, if you decide to sell your inherited coin collection, you may encounter tax obligations, which can vary based on the state you reside in.

To determine whether taxes apply to your inherited coins, it’s advisable to consult with a lawyer or tax expert. They can provide guidance on how tax laws may affect your situation.

Unlock the Value of Your Inherited Coins


Inheriting a coin collection is a unique opportunity that deserves expert guidance. At
Mountain View US and Foreign Coins, we’re here to help you navigate this journey. Our experienced numismatists offer professional appraisals, grading advice, and fair buying prices for your inherited coins. Whether you’re looking to understand, preserve, or sell your collection, our team provides the knowledge and support you need to make informed decisions.

Don’t let uncertainty hold you back from maximizing the potential of your inherited coins. Contact Mountain View US and Foreign Coins today to schedule your consultation. As your trusted coin shop in the Bay Area, we’re ready to help you unlock the true value of your numismatic legacy, whether you’re local or beyond. Take the first step towards turning your inherited coins into a rewarding experience – reach out to us now.

Table of Contents
Share article

Deciding the Best Route: Selling Estate Coins Through an Estate Sale or a Dealer

How Coins Are Graded: Enhancing Your Coin Collecting Journey

Where to Sell Your Old Coins: A Comprehensive Guide

Scroll to Top